Investing without a parachute

Mon, Jun 29, 10:24 AM ET, by , BlackRock

In the wake of the coronavirus crisis, the U.S. bond market finds itself flirting with negative interest rates and bumping up against the “zero lower bound” -- calling into question the ability of bonds to provide ballast in future equity sell-offs.

Rethinking fixed income at the “zero lower bound”

Historically, investors have allocated to fixed income to meet any of three key objectives: capital appreciation, income generation, and preservation of principal. Fixed income's typical ability to provide ballast against equity sell-offs rests in the normal response of lower interest rates to falling stocks -- resulting in a general negative correlation between bonds and stocks. When stock prices fall, bonds prices tend to rise. However, in recent years, super low, zero and even negative interest rates have driven up the value of fixed income securities limiting further capital appreciation and calling into question the asset class's ability to diversify against future equity drawdowns.

At the same time, the coronavirus crisis is pushing the Fed to lower interest rates to zero for the second time in just over a decade. Now, policy makers are bumping up against the “zero lower bound” on interest rates -- or theoretical lowest level that interest rates can fall to before they become unenticing to investors and ineffective as a way to stimulate economic growth.  While it is true that negative rates have been seen in other countries around the world before, the scope of negative rates is limited. Why? Interest rates cannot fall (much) below zero because if they do, investors have the option of holding cash which pays no interest, but that is better than a negative-yielding asset.

In this historically unprecedented period, investors should be rethinking the role of fixed income in portfolio construction and ask themselves: Am I investing without a parachute? The answer requires a reexamination of the Global Financial Crisis and the last bout of zero interest rate policy.

From the fear of rising to the fear rates can't go low enough

After the Global Financial Crisis, the fear was future increases in interest rates. Today, it is the fear interest rates won't be able fall far enough to provide the safety investors expect from bonds.

The below graph puts the discussion in its historical context. The average decline in the Fed's policy rate during recessions averages nearly 400 bps - yet the cuts to zero in response to the coronavirus crisis amount to only 175 bps. For longer maturities, the 10-year interest rate on average falls over 300 bps during recessions. Coming into the coronavirus crisis, the 10-year Treasury stood at around 1.75% and has fallen around 100bps. And unlike during the Global Financial Crisis, further declines in longer term interest rates are clearly more limited. Today the 30-year Treasury yield stands just under 1.4% in contrast to close to 5% in the leadup to the Global Financial Crisis.

This implies simply less room for rates to fall when the Fed needs to again provide future accommodation. With zero as the effective lower bound, potential rate declines from here stand clearly lower than in past recessionary periods, implying less potential for positive fixed income returns to offset negative equity returns. So, bond ballast likely remains, but the ZLB limits its amount. In such an environment, alternative forms of ballast take on even greater importance.

icon-pointer.svgRead Jeff's full take on the outlook for bond markets here.

Exploring alternative forms of portfolio diversification

In the following section we review an alternative approach to adding ballast to a portfolio we call “Defensive Alpha” -- which attempts to take advantage of “dispersion” across a broad universe of equities. There are three key structural components to what can make Defensive Alpha an effective portfolio diversifier which we will now walk-through (see figure below).

1. Equity dispersion has tended to rise when markets fall

First, Defensive Alpha seeks to generate returns based on individual stock performance through long and short positions.  The potential return, or “alpha” available from this type of investment strategy is the degree to which the market differentiates these individual, or “idiosyncratic” characteristics of stock returns relative to each other.  We call this “dispersion.” Higher dispersion is synonymous with events catalyzing greater winners and losers. This is the opposite of the idea that rising tides lift all boats. Falling markets may create greater differentiation between winners and losers and potentially greater return opportunities.

2. Companies with leverage have tended to show increase dispersion

Second, leverage on the balance sheet has increased dispersion. So, a universe of companies using debt may exhibit more dispersion than companies without debt. Limiting the stock selection universe to companies with debt increases the dispersion and hence the potential alpha of our approach.

3. Equity valuations has been more dependent on debt-based metrics during drawdowns

Finally, in good markets the income statement perspective has dominated equity valuation (e.g. revenue growth, net income, EPS). In bad markets, debt-based metrics that are found on the balance sheet rules. This regime dependence of information provides an important third source of structural diversification. The more stressed the environment, the more important debt-based measures of resilience (e.g. indebtedness, liquidity, cash flow and funding costs) become. This increasing relative importance of credit information occurs most strongly when stock markets have fallen in anticipation of recessions and that has tended to increase the defensive nature of the potential alpha returns.

The below figure highlights these important structural characteristics. As you can see, as the volatility of the market rises (pink area), a universe of the most highly levered companies (orange line) display greater levels of dispersion than the typical universe of companies in the S&P 500 (yellow line).

Ultimately, this higher level of dispersion can potentially lead to more opportunities to generate positive returns even when equity markets fall.

Putting it all together

Putting all three of these structural characteristics together can create an alternative form of diversification that may complement the traditional ballast provided by bonds.

Note that while these structural characteristics may be expected to be persistent, not every down stock market is associated with these trends. We have seen occasions when dispersion falls during rapid equity market declines and even quality balance sheet companies under-perform during sell-offs. Hence, these structural characteristics support an expectation, though not a guarantee, of diversification.

The bottom line

In the post-coronavirus investment world, proximity to the ZLB challenges the long-term ability of fixed income to provide diversification for equity portfolios.

Alternative investment approaches such as those targeting Defensive Alpha can provide investors with additional forms of portfolio diversification when bond allocations may not be sufficient.

Jeffrey Rosenberg, CFA, is a senior portfolio manager for BlackRock's Systematic Fixed Income (“SFI”) team and a regular contributor to The Blog.

Investing involves risks, including possible loss of principal. This material is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or to adopt any investment strategy. The opinions expressed are as of June 2020 and may change as subsequent conditions vary. The information and opinions contained in this post are derived from proprietary and non-proprietary sources deemed by BlackRock to be reliable, are not necessarily all-inclusive and are not guaranteed as to accuracy. As such, no warranty of accuracy or reliability is given and no responsibility arising in any other way for errors and omissions (including responsibility to any person by reason of negligence) is accepted by BlackRock, its officers, employees or agents. This post may contain “forward-looking” information that is not purely historical in nature. Such information may include, among other things, projections and forecasts. There is no guarantee that any forecasts made will come to pass. Reliance upon information in this post is at the sole discretion of the reader. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Index performance is shown for illustrative purposes only. You cannot invest directly in an index. ©2020 BlackRock, Inc. All rights reserved. BLACKROCK is a registered trademark of BlackRock, Inc., or its subsidiaries in the United States and elsewhere. All other marks are the property of their respective owners. USRMH0620U-1216816.

Investing without a parachute
Mon, Jun 29, 10:24 AM ET,
by , BlackRock

How alternative data can lend clarity amid uncertainty
Wed, Jun 24, 8:34 AM ET,
by , BlackRock

Don't miss the rise of the “value” phoenix
Tue, Jun 23, 3:04 PM ET,
by , BlackRock

Today's portfolios “Can't get no satisfaction” from yesterday's instruments
Tue, Jun 23, 2:54 PM ET,
by , BlackRock

The Race to Zero
Thu, Jun 18, 8:04 AM ET,
by , BlackRock

More articles:  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 next »

  This   ballast   companies   debt   dispersion   diversification   during   equity   fall   fixed   have   income   information   interest   investors   lower   markets   more   negative   portfolio   provide   rates   returns   that   zero
10 ETFs With Stocks That Insiders Are Buying
10 ETFs With Most Upside To Analyst Targets
25 Dividend Giants Widely Held By ETFs
25 S.A.F.E. Dividend Stocks Increasing Payments For Decades
Broker Darlings: Top 15 Analyst Picks of the Dow
Top 25 Broker Analyst Picks of the S&P 500
Forgotten S&P 500 Giants: Analysts' Current Least Favorites
25 Top Ranked Socially Responsible Dividend Stocks
10 Oversold ETFs
The Top 10 DividendRank'ed Stocks
Warren Buffett Dividend Stocks
The DividendRank Top 25
The Top 10 DividendRank'ed DJIA Components
The Top 10 DividendRank'ed Dow Transports Components
The Top 10 DividendRank'ed Dow Utilities Components
The Top 10 DividendRank'ed Nasdaq 100 Components
10 Stocks Going Ex-Dividend
10 Oversold Dividend Stocks
10 Stocks Where Yields Got More Juicy
10 Dividend Bargains You Can Buy Cheaper Than Insiders Did
Top Ranked Dividend Stocks With Insider Buying
10 Energy Stocks You Can Buy Cheaper Than Insiders Did
10 Metals Stocks You Can Buy Cheaper Than Insiders Did
10 Oversold Metals Stocks
10 Must-Know High-Yield REITs
10 Top DividendRank'ed Financials
10 Top DividendRank'ed Metals Stocks
10 Oversold Energy Stocks
10 Top DividendRank'ed Energy Stocks
10 Top DividendRank'ed Utility Stocks
10 Stocks Crossing Below Book Value
10 Stocks Crossing Above Their 200 Day Moving Average
10 Stocks Crossing Below Their 200 Day Moving Average
10 ETFs Crossing Above Their 200 DMA
The 10 Biggest ETFs
The 10 Best ETF Performers
Best Vanguard ETFs By TTM Performance
Worst Vanguard ETFs By TTM Performance
Best iShares ETFs By TTM Performance
Worst iShares ETFs By TTM Performance
The 10 Worst ETF Performers
10 ETFs With Notable Inflows
10 ETFs With Notable Outflows
Top 10 Analyst Rated Consumer Stocks
Top 10 Analyst Rated Dividend Stocks
Top 10 Analyst Rated Energy Stocks
Top 10 Analyst Rated Financial Stocks
Top 10 Analyst Rated Healthcare Stocks
Top 10 Analyst Rated REIT Stocks
Top 10 Analyst Rated Technology Stocks
Best Dividend Stocks 2000-2020
Best High Dividend Stocks 2000-2020
Top Dividend Stocks 2010-2020
Best High Yield Stocks 2010-2020
Top Dividend Stocks 2015-2020
Top High Dividend Yield Stocks 2015-2020
The Top 10 DividendRank'ed Canadian Stocks
The DividendRank Canada Top 25
10 Canadian Stocks Going Ex-Dividend
10 Oversold Canadian Stocks
10 Canadian Stocks Where Yields Got More Juicy
10 Must-Know High-Yield Canadian Real Estate Stocks
10 Top DividendRank'ed Canadian Financials
10 Must-Know High-Yield Canadian Energy Stocks
10 Canadian Stocks Crossing Below Book Value
10 Canadian Stocks Crossing Above Their 200 Day Moving Avg
10 Canadian Stocks Crossing Below Their 200 Day Moving Avg
Stock market game

ETF Articles | ETF Channel |

Copyright © 2010 - 2020, All Rights Reserved Nothing in ETF Channel is intended to be investment advice, nor does it represent the opinion of, counsel from, or recommendations by BNK Invest Inc. or any of its affiliates, subsidiaries or partners. None of the information contained herein constitutes a recommendation that any particular security, portfolio, transaction, or investment strategy is suitable for any specific person. All viewers agree that under no circumstances will BNK Invest, Inc,. its subsidiaries, partners, officers, employees, affiliates, or agents be held liable for any loss or damage caused by your reliance on information obtained. By visiting, using or viewing this site, you agree to the following Full Disclaimer & Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Video widget and ETF videos powered by Market News Video. Quote data delayed at least 20 minutes; data powered by Ticker Technologies, and Mergent. Contact ETF Channel; Meet Our Editorial Staff.